No, Christmas Is Not Based on a Pagan Holiday
By Lenny Esposito
Give Yourself—or a Friend—the Gift of Knowledge!
Would you like to grow in your knowledge of the Christian worldview and your ability to defend it? Subscribe to The Worldview Bulletin for only $2.50 per month and learn from world-class Christian scholars and apologists. You’ll receive our free weekly email as well as our subscriber-only monthly newsletter.
Or, to give a gift subscription that a friend or family member will benefit from the whole year, visit here.
Be equipped, informed, and encouraged!
“The Worldview Bulletin is a must-have resource for everyone who’s committed to spreading and defending the faith. It’s timely, always relevant, frequently eye-opening, and it never fails to encourage, inspire, and equip.”
— Lee Strobel, New York Times bestselling author of more than forty books and founding director of the Lee Strobel Center for Evangelism and Applied Apologetics
“The Worldview Bulletin is a wonderful resource for the church. It’s timely and helpful.” — Sean McDowell, associate professor in the Christian Apologetics program at Talbot School of Theology and author of The Fate of the Apostles: Examining the Martyrdom Accounts of the Closest Followers of Jesus (Routledge)
Christmas is a much-beloved holiday, celebrated by billions of people across the globe. In the U.S. alone, the Pew Center reports that nearly 96% of the population celebrates Christmas, including eight out of ten non-Christians, including atheists, agnostics, and those who have no faith commitment.[1] However, Christmas is also a uniquely Christian holiday; its core message is about a personal God taking humanity upon Himself and stepping into the world to redeem sinful human beings who could never redeem themselves. The Christian message is inescapable.
I believe the love of Christmas coupled with the loathing of Christianity is one reason why atheists continue to repeat the claim that Christmas is a repurposing of a pagan Roman holiday. Two of the most popular pagan holidays put forth are the celebration of Saturnalia, which honored the Roman god Saturn, or the Dies Natalis of Sol Invictus, which is the “Birthday of the Unconquerable Sun.” Both of these celebrations were held in the second half of December, making them somewhat close to Christmas.
The claim that the roots of Christmas are pagan isn't new. The New England Puritans, who valued work more than celebration, taught such.[2] Increase Mather preached that “the early Christians who first observed the Nativity on December 25 did not do so thinking that ‘Christ was born in that Month, but because the Heathens Saturnalia was at that time kept in Rome, and they were willing to have those Pagan Holidays metamorphosed into Christian.’”[3]
When one digs into the actual history, however, a much different picture arises. There are two ways to approach the question: one is to see how December 25 became associated with the Nativity, which is how the early church would have referred to the day of Christ's birth. The other is to look at the celebrations like Saturnalia and Sol Invictus. Let’s explore both.
Looking at the History of Christmas
Much of the thrust of the “pagan Christmas” claim rests on the idea of a Christianized Rome trying to convert a populace that wouldn't want to give up its feast traditions, akin to the practice of churches celebrating a “Harvest Festival” instead of Halloween. Yet, scholars like Yale University's T.C. Schmidt find the marking of December 25 to appear much earlier in Christian history.
When translating Hippolytus' Commentary on Daniel, written just after AD 200, Schmidt notes that five of the seven manuscripts contain December 25 as the date for Jesus' birth and another offers the 25th of either December or March.[4] Clement of Alexandria in this same time offers the date of March 25 as the date of the incarnation—that is, the conception of Jesus—in his Stromata (1.21.145-146).[5] Both works assert the idea that Jesus' death would have happened on the same day as his conception.
Christmas and Easter are Linked
Why the December 25th date? As Thomas Tulley works out in his book The Origins of the Liturgical Year, early church members believed the date of the death of Jesus would also reflect either his birth or his conception.[6] Augustine wrote of this, saying, “For He is believed to have been conceived on the 25th of March, upon which day also He suffered; so the womb of the Virgin, in which He was conceived, where no one of mortals was begotten, corresponds to the new grave in which He was buried, wherein was never man laid, neither before nor since. But He was born, according to tradition, upon December the 25th.”[7]
St. John Chrysostom goes ever further, noting the Angel Gabriel's announcement of Mary's conception happened while Elizabeth was six months pregnant with John the Baptist (Luke 1:26). Chrysostom argues Zechariah's service was the Day of Atonement, thus making the conception of John the Baptist happen in the fall. Add six months and Jesus's conception lands in the spring, that is, March 25. I don't know if this calculation is accurate, but it shows how much the early church tied the events together. The idea of randomly choosing a pagan date instead seems a pretty big stretch.
Here's the thing. If Christians were recognizing the birth of Christ by the beginning of the third century, does it make sense to think that this was a fourth century invention to sway the Roman populous over to Christianity? Christianity was gaining ground in the time of Clement, but it was by no means out from under the shadow of persecution. It also wasn't borrowing much from pagan customs at the time. So why believe they would do so for this date?
Roman Time and Saturnalia
What about the year-end Roman celebration of Saturnalia, though? When studying this holiday, one primary source is Macrobius, a Roman who lived in the fifth century. His Saturnalia provides details on the origin stories of the celebration as well as its customs. T.C. Schmidt highlights this passage from Saturnalia book 1, chapter 10, giving the dates of the celebration:
Our ancestors restricted the Saturnalia to a single day, the fourteenth before the Kalends of January, but, after Gaius Caesar had added two days to December, the day on which the festival was held became the sixteenth before the Kalends of January [January 1], with the result that, since the exact day was not commonly known—some observing the addition which Caesar had made to the calendar and others following the old usage —the festival came to be regarded as lasting for more days than one.
And yet in fact among the men of old time there were some who supposed that the Saturnalia lasted for seven days…
[But] one can infer, then, from all that has been said, that the Saturnalia lasted but one day and was held only on the fourteenth day before the Kalends of January; it was on this day alone that the shout of "Io Saturnalia" would be raised, in the temple of Saturn, at a riotous feast. Now, however, during the celebration of the Saturnalia, this day is allotted to the festival of the Opalia, although the day was first assigned to Saturn and Ops in common.[8]
So Saturnalia was a three-day long feast that began sixteen days before January 1st. Their December was 31 days long as is ours, which places Saturnalia on December 17, far too early to be mistaken for December 25. However, Macrobius notes that another celebration, Sigillaria, was celebrated after these three days. Schmidt in his article provides a translation of chapter ten in its entirety, as dates are referenced throughout. He then concludes:
Macrobius does an excellent job summarizing authorities that were available to him, most of which I think have been lost. His conclusion is quite clear, Saturnalia originally was one day and occurred on the 14th day before the Kalends January, but when Caesar altered the calendar it was extended to three days and started on the 16th, later a new Festival of Sigillaria extended the celebrations to complete seven days, meaning that the Festival ended on either the 10th or ninth day before the Kalends of January depending on how we count. Of course neither of these days fall on the eighth day before the Kalends of January, that is December 25.[9]
The Dates Don't Fit
Remember, Macrobius was writing in the fifth century AD and we have Christmas sermons from John Chrysostom preached on December 25th from a century earlier. Yet the dates don't correspond. If Christmas was created to supplant Saturnalia, the Christians would have chosen December 17th. Add to that the references I noted about the December 25th date stretching all the way back to A.D. 200 and you have a very real problem with Saturnalia being the origin of the date for Christmas.
Imagine a modern church seeking to replace Halloween celebrations by having a Harvest festival on November 8. It wouldn't work! People could celebrate one and then attend the other. The concept of substitution would be fairly ineffective in such a case.
There is one other possibility suggested when discussing Christmas borrowing from pagan Rome: Sol Invictus—the winter solstice. Unfortunately, I don’t have the space to explore it here. However, you can read about why that suggestion fails as well by visiting https://apologetics-notes.comereason.org/2015/12/christmas-solstice-and-december-25th.html.
I hope this little study has encouraged you to see that sometimes historic coincidences aren’t always significant. Our assumptions can be very wrong sometimes! You may celebrate the coming of Jesus confidently knowing this is a very Christian holiday, and let me wish you a very merry and blessed Christmas!
References
[1] Besheer Mohammed. “Christmas Also Celebrated by Many Non-Christians.” Pew Research Center. Pew Research Center, 23 Dec. 2013. Web. 14 Dec. 2015. http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2013/12/23/christmas-also-celebrated-by-many-non-christians/.
[2] Rachel N. Schnepper. “Yuletide's Outlaws.” The New York Times. 14 Dec. 2012. Web. 15 Dec. 2015.http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/15/opinion/the-puritan-war-on-christmas.html?_r=0
[3] Stephen Nissenbaum. The Battle for Christmas. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1996. Print. 4.
[4] T.C. Schmidt. “Hippolytus and the Original Date of Christmas” Chronicon.net. T.C. Schmidt. 21 Nov 2010. Web. http://web.archive.org/web/20130303163053/http://chronicon.net/blog/chronology/hippolytus-and-the-original-date-of-christmas 16 Dec 2015.
[5] T.C. Schmidt. “Clement of Alexandria and the Original date of Christmas as December 25th.” Chrinicon.net. T.C. Schmidt. 17 Dec 2010. Web. http://web.archive.org/web/20120822053409/http://chronicon.net/blog/hippolytus/clement-of-alexandria-and-the-original-date-of-christmas-as-december-25th/ 16 Dec 2015.
[6] Thomas J. Talley. The Origins of the Liturgical Year. New York: Pueblo Pub, 1986. Print. 91ff.
[7] Augustine of Hippo. On the Trinity, IV, 5. Logos Virtual Library. Trans. Arthur West Haddan. Darren L. Slider, n.d. Web. 16 Dec. 2015. http://www.logoslibrary.org/augustine/trinity/0405.html.
[8] T.C. Schmidt. “The dates of Saturnalia (and Sigillaria!) and Christmas.” Chronicon.net. T.C. Schmidt. 18 Dec 2010. Web. https://web.archive.org/web/20140721073230/http:/chronicon.net/blog/christmas/the-dates-of-saturnalia-and-sigillaria-and-christmas/
[9] Ibid.
— Author, speaker, and debater Lenny Esposito has been spreading convincing Christianity across the globe by stirring the hearts and minds of the lost and the church for over twenty years. A pioneer in online apologetics with his popular ComeReason.org website and podcast, Lenny has also contributed to books such as the award-winning Apologetics Study Bible for Students (B&H, 2010), A New Kind of Apologist (Harvest House, 2016), and True Reason: Confronting the Irrationality of the New Atheism (Kregel, 2014). His articles have appeared in the Los Angeles Times and the Southern California Christian Times.
Image by Gerhard G. from Pixabay
Believing Philosophy
Philosophy has been a part of Christianity since its earliest days. But Christians today often don't realize or are skeptical of all that philosophy can offer them. Believing Philosophy introduces Christians to philosophy and the tools it provides to believers, helping them understand, articulate, and defend their faith in an age of unbelief.
Along with explaining how and why Christians should study philosophy, philosopher Dolores Morris also surveys key issues in Christian philosophy, including:
The problem of evil
Rationality and faith
Free will
Skeptical theism
The moral argument for the existence of God
Reformed epistemology
These chapters introduce each problem, explain Christian responses, discuss the strengths and weaknesses of each response, and leave the final verdict to the reader. Finally, each chapter concludes with a list of recommended further readings.
“Dolores Morris’s accessible book on Christian philosophy is a wonderful gateway to understanding the relationship between faith and reason. Morris works through caricatures and misrepresentations about philosophy, and she presents important arguments and analyzes issues to show how philosophy under the lordship of Christ can be a vital, faith-shaping tool both for individual Christians and the overall well-being of the church.”
— Paul Copan, Pledger Family Chair of Philosophy and Ethics, Palm Beach Atlantic University
See our recent excerpt from Believing Philosophy on the Free Will Defense here.
Find Believing Philosophy at Amazon, Zondervan Academic, and other major booksellers.
* This is a sponsored post.
News
What is the Relation between Science and Religion?
Virtue, Human Nature and the Quest for Happiness
Where Are All the Heretical Bishops in the Second Century?
Christianity Today’s 2022 Book Awards
10 significant international human rights events of 2021
Fewer than half of American adults pray daily; religiously unaffiliated grows: study
17 Missionaries leave Haiti after kidnapping, everyone doing ‘reasonably well’ CAM reveals
Podcast: The Universe is No Accident, Dr. Luke Barnes
Video: Cultural Apologetics with Dr. Paul Gould
Video: Different Genealogies for Jesus - Contradictions in the Bible?
Video: John Polkinghorne - Why the Cosmos?
(*The views expressed in the articles and media linked to do not necessarily represent the views of the editors of The Worldview Bulletin.)
Book Deals and Resources
Look here for Faithlife’s free eBook of the Month.
Visit here to get the Logos Free Book of the Month. You can download the free version of Logos which will allow you to access the monthly free books. Logos 9 is a great investment, though, and has tons of tools that make Bible study easier and richer. New users can get 50% off of the Logos 9 Fundamentals package, which discounts it to $49.99.
Get a second free book of the month here.
See the Logos Monthly Sale for dozens of good deals, as well as the Logos Christmas Sale, for resources up to 60% off.
Christianaudio free download for December: A Christmas Carol.
Audiobook: Praying with Paul: A Call to Spiritual Formation by D. A. Carson, $2.99
Audiobook: The Abolition of Man and The Great Divorce by C. S. Lewis, $1.99
Stream the ESV Bible for free on ESV.org or the ESV Bible app on iOs and Android. Read by award-winning modern hymn writer Kristyn Getty. You can also audio stream the Bible in a few different translations using the new Bible Gateway Audio app.
The latest issue of Themelios is available and free.
Eerdmans Year-End eBook Sale – 850 Titles up to 80% off!
Bringing the Gospel Home: Witnessing to Family Members, Close Friends, and Others Who Know You Well by Randy Newman, $4.99
18 Words: The Most Important Words You Will Ever Know by J. I. Packer, $2.99
Basic Christianity by John Stott, $2.99
A Little Book for New Theologians: Why and How to Study Theology by Kelly Kapic, $3.99
52 Little Lessons from It's a Wonderful Life by Bob Welch, $1.99
Open and Unafraid: The Psalms as a Guide to Life by W. David O. Taylor, $1.99
Jesus on Every Page: 10 Simple Ways to Seek and Find Christ in the Old Testament by David Murray, $1.99
Walking Through Twilight: A Wife's Illness—A Philosopher's Lament by Douglas Groothuis, $3.99
Loving God with Your Mind: Essays in Honor of J. P. Moreland ed. by Paul Gould and Richard Brian Davis, $2.99